Start by checking the lawyer’s license and discipline history on the State Bar of California’s website. Then ask whether they have handled cases like yours, who will actually do the work, and what the fee terms are, in a written agreement, before you sign anything. A good fit is a lawyer who answers those questions plainly, without pressure and without promises.
A list of names or a high search ranking can’t tell you whether a lawyer is right for your case. The answers to the questions below can. If you were hurt in an accident, our Orange County personal injury lawyer page explains how we help.
Step 1: Check the lawyer’s license and discipline history
Every California lawyer has a free public profile on the State Bar of California’s website, and checking it takes about two minutes. Go to calbar.ca.gov, open the attorney search, and look up the lawyer by name or State Bar number.
- License status. It should show the lawyer is active and eligible to practice. A suspended, inactive or disbarred lawyer can’t represent you.
- Public discipline. The profile lists any public discipline the State Bar has imposed. One old issue isn’t always a deal-breaker, but you deserve to know about it and to hear the lawyer explain it.
- Admission date. This tells you how long the lawyer has been licensed in California.
It’s also fair to ask whether the lawyer carries professional liability insurance, which covers a lawyer’s own mistakes. Under California Rule of Professional Conduct 1.4.2, a lawyer who doesn’t carry it generally must tell you so in writing at the start. Insurance is a separate question from whether the firm can advance case costs like experts and depositions, so ask about both.
Has the lawyer handled cases like yours?
Ask how much of the lawyer’s work involves your type of case, because a rear-end crash, a truck collision and a fall in a store are proven in very different ways. A lawyer who regularly handles your kind of case knows what evidence matters, which experts are needed and what the defense usually argues.
Three things are worth asking about:
- Case-type experience. Ask how many cases like yours the lawyer has handled recently. A car accident claim turns on different proof than a brain injury case or a premises claim.
- Resources for serious injuries. Serious cases often need medical experts, accident reconstruction, life-care planners or economists. Ask whether the office can advance those costs and how they’re repaid.
- Caseload. Ask how many active cases the lawyer is handling. You want someone with time to return your calls and push your case forward.
Who will actually handle your case?
Ask by name who will handle your case day to day, because the lawyer you meet first isn’t always the one who does the work. Some offices sign up cases and then refer them to another firm. Others pass most of the work to staff you never meet.
Neither is automatically wrong, but you should know up front. Ask who will talk to the insurance adjuster, who will take depositions if there’s a lawsuit, and who will stand up in court. If your case will be shared with a lawyer at a different firm, California Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5.1 requires full written disclosure and your written consent to the fee split.
Is the lawyer prepared to file suit and try the case if needed?
Most injury cases settle, but you want a lawyer who is ready to file a lawsuit and take your case to a jury if a fair settlement doesn’t come. Insurers decide what to offer partly by weighing what could happen at trial.
Ask whether the lawyer personally tries cases, and what happens to your case if the insurer won’t make a reasonable offer. Keep in mind that a lawyer’s past results never predict the outcome of your case. What you’re learning is whether they are prepared to go the distance.
How will the lawyer keep you informed?
Ask how often you’ll hear about your case, by what method, and who to call when you have a question. Agreeing on this up front is much easier than fixing weeks of silence later.
California’s ethics rules require lawyers to keep clients reasonably informed. Under Rule 1.4.1, your lawyer must also promptly tell you the amounts and terms of any written settlement offer. And under Rule 1.2, the decision to accept or reject a settlement is yours, not the lawyer’s.
What should the fee agreement say?
In California, a contingency fee agreement must be in writing, and the lawyer must give you a signed copy. “Contingency” means the fee is a percentage of what you recover. Under Business and Professions Code section 6147, the agreement must state the fee percentage, how case costs affect the fee and your recovery, whether you could owe anything for related matters it doesn’t cover, and that the fee is not set by law and is negotiable.
If an agreement doesn’t meet these requirements, you can choose to void it, and the lawyer is then limited to a reasonable fee. Before you sign, ask three practical questions. Is the percentage calculated before or after costs are paid back? Does it change if a lawsuit is filed? And who pays the case costs if there’s no recovery?
For the fuller picture, read how much it costs to hire a personal injury lawyer in California.
Questions to ask at your consultation
| Question to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Is your license active, and have you ever been disciplined? | You can confirm it on the State Bar website. A straight answer is a good sign. |
| How many cases like mine have you handled? | Experience with your type of injury and accident shapes how the case is built. |
| Can your office fund the experts my case may need? | Serious injuries often need medical and technical experts before a case can be valued. |
| Who will handle my case day to day? | You should know who negotiates, who appears in court and who returns your calls. |
| Will my case be referred to or shared with another firm? | A fee split between firms requires written disclosure and your written consent. |
| Are you prepared to file suit and try my case if needed? | Insurers weigh what could happen at trial when deciding what to offer. |
| How and how often will you update me? | Clear expectations up front prevent long silences later. |
| What is the fee, and how are case costs handled? | Both must be in the written agreement, and both affect what you take home. |
| What are the weak spots in my case? | A lawyer who only shares good news may not be giving you the full picture. |
You don’t need to ask every question. Pick the ones that matter most to you, and write down the answers so you can compare.
What should you bring to your first consultation?
Bring whatever paperwork you already have, so the lawyer can give you real answers instead of guesses. Don’t worry if you’re missing things. A good lawyer will tell you what to gather next.
- The police or accident report, or at least the report number
- Photos of the scene, the vehicles and your injuries
- Letters from any insurance company, with claim numbers
- Medical records or discharge papers, and any bills you’ve received
- Any letter or notice that mentions a deadline
- Names and phone numbers of witnesses
How we answer these questions
We think you should hold us to the same standard. Faud Haghighi’s State Bar number is 281724, so you can check his license and record on his State Bar profile in a couple of minutes. You can read about his background on our About page.
Red flags to watch for
Be cautious of any lawyer or office that guarantees a result, pressures you to sign on the spot, or reached you through someone who approached you after the accident.
- Guarantees. Be cautious of any lawyer who guarantees an outcome or promises a specific amount before the facts are known.
- Pressure to sign now. You should be able to take the agreement home, read it and ask questions first.
- Uninvited contact. Under Rule of Professional Conduct 7.3, California generally restricts lawyers from soliciting new clients for financial gain through unsolicited in-person visits, live calls, or real-time electronic contact, with limited exceptions (for example, other lawyers, family, or people with a close personal or prior professional relationship). A surprise visit to your hospital room or an unexpected call about your accident is a bad sign.
- Runners and cappers. Business and Professions Code section 6152 makes it unlawful to act as a “runner” or “capper,” someone who steers injured people to a lawyer, in places like hospitals and public streets. Be wary if a tow driver, body shop or stranger pushes a particular lawyer on you.
- Vague fees. If the lawyer won’t put the fee in writing or can’t explain how costs work, keep looking.
Does your lawyer need to be in Orange County?
Any lawyer licensed in California can handle your case, but local experience helps. Most Orange County injury lawsuits are filed in Orange County Superior Court, and many are heard at the Central Justice Center in Santa Ana. A lawyer who works there regularly knows how its procedures run. Read more about how an injury case moves through Orange County Superior Court.
Being close by also makes meetings easier while you recover, whether you live in Irvine or elsewhere in the county.
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch lawyers if I’m unhappy with mine?
Yes. In California you can end the relationship with your lawyer at any time, with or without a reason, and you’re entitled to your file. Your former lawyer may still claim a fee for the reasonable value of the work already done (Fracasse v. Brent (1972) 6 Cal.3d 784), handled under your fee agreements and the law. Before you switch, ask the new lawyer how any prior fee claim will be handled.
Is what I tell a lawyer in a free consultation confidential?
Generally, yes. Under California Rule of Professional Conduct 1.18, a lawyer must protect confidential information you share while deciding whether to hire them, even if you don’t end up hiring that lawyer. Still, a consultation alone doesn’t make the lawyer your lawyer. That only happens once you both agree to the representation.
Should I go with the lawyer I see most in ads or online rankings?
Ads and rankings tell you who markets the most, not who will handle your case or how. Use them as a starting point if you like, then check the State Bar profile and ask the same questions you’d ask anyone else. The answers matter more than the ad.
When should you talk to a lawyer after an accident?
Sooner is usually better, and a consultation doesn’t commit you to anything. It’s worth calling if:
- your injuries need ongoing treatment or have kept you from work,
- the insurer disputes fault, delays, or asks you for a recorded statement,
- you’ve received an early offer or a release to sign,
- a city, county or OCTA may be involved, since those claims have a six-month deadline, or
- a doctor offers to treat you on a lien, or a letter mentions a deadline.
Ask us these questions too
We welcome every question on this list. Learn more about our Orange County personal injury practice, and when you’re ready, contact our office or call (949) 313-7656 for a free consultation.
This article is general information about California law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
