Law Offices of Faud Haghighi

Comparative Fault in California: What If You Were Partly to Blame?

Yes, you can still recover compensation in California even if you were partly to blame for your accident. Under California’s “pure comparative fault” rule, your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault. It isn’t wiped out, even if your share is large.

Being told “you were partly at fault” doesn’t mean you have no claim. Fault is a percentage that has to be supported by evidence, and it is one of the most commonly disputed issues in an injury claim. If you were hurt and the other side is blaming you, our Orange County personal injury lawyer page explains how we help.

What does “pure comparative fault” mean?

Pure comparative fault means your damages are generally reduced by your percentage of responsibility. Separate rules decide how multiple defendants share the bill, especially for economic vs. non-economic damages (more on that below). California adopted this rule in Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975), a California Supreme Court case. Before that, a person who was even slightly at fault could recover nothing.

Some states still cut off recovery once you are 50% or 51% at fault. California doesn’t. A person who was 70% at fault can still recover the 30% caused by the other party.

How the math works

First the total value of your damages is decided, then it is reduced by your percentage of fault. At trial, the jury decides both numbers separately, and the court does the subtraction. These are the rules in California’s standard jury instructions, CACI 405 and 406. In settlement talks, both sides run the same math.

Your share of faultTotal damagesWhat you can recover
0%$100,000$100,000
20%$100,000$80,000
50%$100,000$50,000
75%$100,000$25,000
90%$100,000$10,000

Illustrative round numbers only, to show the math. They are not an estimate of any real case.

Who decides how much fault is yours?

Early on, fault is argued between your side and the insurance company. If the case goes to trial, a jury decides. At trial, the defense has to prove two things: that you were negligent, and that your negligence was a substantial factor in causing your harm. You don’t have to prove you were blameless.

The police report isn’t the final word

Police reports often carry weight in settlement talks, but the officer usually didn’t see the crash. The report is based on statements and a look at the scene. Vehicle Code section 20013 bars using the accident report itself as evidence at a trial arising from the crash.

The report doesn’t decide civil fault. Whether the officer’s testimony, or the evidence behind the report, can be used depends on the evidence rules.

The officer can still testify about what they saw and measured, and a qualified officer may give opinions on things like the point of impact or speed. But an officer’s opinion on who was “most at fault” is generally treated as a legal conclusion for the jury, not proper expert testimony.

What really decides fault is the evidence, such as:

  • Video from dashcams, doorbell cameras, businesses, and traffic cameras
  • Photos of the scene, the vehicles, and where the damage is
  • Independent witnesses who don’t know either side
  • Data from a vehicle’s event data recorder (speed, braking, and throttle before impact)
  • Signal timing records, skid marks, sightlines, and lighting at the scene
  • Phone records, if distraction is in question

What if more than one party was at fault?

You can collect the full amount of your economic damages from any responsible defendant, less your own share of fault, but each defendant pays only its own percentage of your non-economic damages. This rule comes from Proposition 51, passed by voters in 1986 and found in Civil Code section 1431.2.

  • Economic damages are losses with a price tag: medical bills, lost wages, and repair costs. In cases where joint-and-several liability applies, after your own share of fault is subtracted, you can collect the rest from any defendant who is responsible.
  • Non-economic damages are losses like pain, suffering, and emotional distress. For these, each defendant pays only its own share of fault.

An example shows why that matters. Say a jury finds Driver A 70% at fault and Driver B 30% at fault, you were not at fault, and Driver B has no insurance or assets. Driver A can still be made to pay all of your economic damages. But Driver A pays only 70% of your non-economic damages, and Driver B’s 30% may never be collected.

Fault can also be assigned to someone who isn’t in the case at all, like a hit-and-run driver who was never found. That lowers what the other defendants owe for non-economic damages.

Your own uninsured motorist coverage may be another source of recovery if an uninsured or unidentified driver contributed to the crash. Eligibility depends on the policy and statutory conditions, such as physical-contact and reporting rules. Our guide to UM/UIM claims explains those rules.

Can being partly at fault ever bar your claim?

In ordinary accidents, no, but in sports and some recreational activities a different rule, “primary assumption of risk,” can block a claim entirely. In Knight v. Jewett (1992), the California Supreme Court held that this doctrine survived the switch to comparative fault.

The idea is that some activities carry risks that are part of the activity itself, like getting knocked down in a pickup football game. A fellow participant is generally liable only for intentionally injuring you or for conduct so reckless it is totally outside the range of ordinary activity in the sport. Other defendants, such as an organizer or facility, still generally have a duty not to increase the risks beyond those inherent in the activity. Whether this rule applies is a legal question for the judge, and it depends heavily on the activity and who is being sued.

Common situations where fault gets shared

  • Rear-end crash. The other side may argue you stopped suddenly or your brake lights were out. What usually matters: the rear driver usually bears most of the fault for following too closely, but not always.
  • Left turn at an intersection. The other side may argue the straight-through driver was speeding or ran a yellow. What usually matters: the turning driver must yield to oncoming traffic, plus speed and signal timing evidence.
  • Pedestrian outside a crosswalk. The other side may argue you crossed mid-block or stepped out suddenly. What usually matters: since 2023 (the Freedom to Walk Act), police generally can’t stop a pedestrian for crossing outside a crosswalk unless there was an immediate danger of a collision. Pedestrians must still use due care, and so must drivers.
  • Slip and fall. The other side may argue the hazard was “open and obvious,” or you were looking at your phone. What usually matters: whether you had a practical choice to avoid it, and how long the hazard was there.
  • Motorcycle crash. The other side may point to lane splitting, speed, or no helmet. What usually matters: California law recognizes lane splitting (Vehicle Code section 21658.1). The question is whether the rider was riding safely for conditions, and what caused each injury.

General examples only. Fault always depends on the specific facts.

Our separate guides on pedestrian accident fault and motorcycle lane splitting go deeper on those two situations. For more on specific accidents, see our pages on car accidents, pedestrian accidents, and motorcycle accidents.

“Open and obvious” in fall cases

In a fall case, property owners often argue the hazard was obvious, so it was your fault for not seeing it. In California, an obvious hazard may mean the owner didn’t need to post a warning. But it doesn’t automatically excuse the owner from fixing it, especially if people had no practical way around it. The outcome depends on the owner’s duty, the circumstances, whether the hazard could reasonably be avoided, and your own conduct. It isn’t always just a split of fault. Learn more about the defenses property owners raise.

Seat belts and helmets: a damages argument

Not wearing a seat belt doesn’t make you responsible for the crash itself. Instead, the defense may argue it made your injuries worse. Under CACI 712, they must prove a working belt was available, a reasonably careful person would have used it, and your injuries would have been avoided or less severe with it.

Insurers make a similar argument when a motorcyclist wasn’t wearing a helmet, which California requires under Vehicle Code section 27803. In general, the argument only reaches injuries a helmet would have prevented or lessened, such as a head injury, not a broken leg. These arguments usually need medical or engineering experts to prove.

Why fault percentages are so often disputed

Because the fault percentage changes a settlement’s value, insurers and injured people often disagree about it. The evidence matters more than either side’s first estimate. On a claim with $200,000 in damages, for example, each 10% shift is $20,000.

Things that often shape the fault discussion:

  • Recorded statements. A casual “I didn’t see them” or “I’m so sorry” can be quoted later as an admission. Read should you give a recorded statement?
  • The police report. It is often cited in negotiations, but it doesn’t decide civil fault.
  • Hindsight arguments. Claims like “you could have swerved” are tested against evidence of how much time you actually had to react.
  • Social media. Posts and photos can be taken out of context to suggest you were careless or not really hurt.
  • Waiting. The longer a claim sits, the more likely video gets erased and witnesses forget.

Frequently asked questions

Can I recover if I was 80% or 90% at fault?

Generally, yes. Under pure comparative fault, your recovery is reduced by your share but not barred, so at 90% fault you could recover 10% of your proven damages. You still have to prove the other party was negligent and that it caused your harm, and defenses such as primary assumption of risk can still apply. Keep in mind the other party may also have a claim against you for their own losses.

Does comparative fault apply in a wrongful death case?

Yes. If the person who died was partly at fault, the family’s recovery is reduced by that percentage, just as the person’s own recovery would have been (CACI 407). The defense has to prove the person was negligent and that it was a substantial factor in the death. See our Orange County wrongful death lawyer page.

Does comparative fault apply to defective product claims?

Yes. In Daly v. General Motors (1978), the California Supreme Court extended comparative fault to strict product liability. If you misused a product or were otherwise careless, your recovery can be reduced by your share, but your carelessness doesn’t erase the manufacturer’s responsibility for a defect. Learn more on our Orange County product liability lawyer page.

When should you talk to a lawyer about shared fault?

It’s worth getting advice early if any of these apply:

  • The insurer has assigned you a fault percentage, or the police report blames you.
  • More than one driver or party may share fault, or one of them has no insurance.
  • Key evidence, such as business video or vehicle data, could be erased soon.
  • The insurer wants a recorded statement about how the accident happened.
  • The defense says a missing seat belt or helmet made your injuries worse.

Were you told you were partly at fault?

An insurer’s fault percentage is a starting position, not a final finding. If you were hurt in Orange County and the other side is blaming you, we can look at the evidence and explain where you stand. Contact our office or call (949) 313-7656 for a free consultation.

This article is general information about California law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Dollar figures and percentages are illustrative examples, not predictions. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

No Fee Unless We Win

Free Case Review

Speak directly with an attorney about your injury — at no cost.

(949) 313-7656 Request a Consultation
Faud Haghighi, Esq., Orange County personal injury attorney
Meet Your Attorney

Faud Haghighi, Esq.

Founder & Lead Trial Attorney

An Orange County trial attorney representing people injured by someone else's negligence — in car and truck crashes, slip-and-falls, premises accidents, and other serious-injury cases. Faud builds each case with the right medical and liability experts, preserves the evidence early, and prepares every file for trial — and you work directly with him, start to finish.

CA State Bar since 2012 · Aliso Viejo & Tustin

Free Consultation Read full bio ›