You keep the “net” settlement: the total amount minus the attorney fee, case costs, and any medical liens or reimbursement claims that must be paid back. How much that leaves depends on your fee agreement, how much was spent on the case, and how far the liens can be reduced.
The gap between the settlement number and the check you receive is often biggest in smaller cases. The examples below show why. If you were hurt in an accident and are weighing a settlement, our Orange County personal injury lawyer page explains how we can help.
Gross vs. net: what’s the difference?
The gross settlement is the full amount the insurance company agrees to pay. The net settlement is what reaches you after everything owed from it is paid. Three things usually come out of the gross: the attorney fee, case costs, and liens.
The size of the gross depends on the value of your claim. See how much a personal injury case is worth in California for what drives that number.
What the math looks like at three settlement sizes
These are made-up, round numbers to show the steps. Each uses the same example fee of 33% of the gross, and liens are shown after reductions. Notice how medical liens take a much bigger bite out of a small settlement.
| Example settlement | What comes out, and your net |
|---|---|
| $25,000 case | Fee $8,250 · costs $1,000 · liens and reimbursement $8,000. Net to you: $7,750 (about 31% of the gross). |
| $100,000 case | Fee $33,000 · costs $4,000 · liens and reimbursement $19,000. Net to you: $44,000 (44%). |
| $500,000 case | Fee $165,000 · costs $25,000 · liens and reimbursement $40,000. Net to you: $270,000 (54%). |
Hypothetical examples only, not typical of any case or fee agreement and not a prediction. Your fee rate, costs and liens are set by your own agreement and case.
A lien has two numbers that matter: the amount billed or asserted, and the amount the lienholder can legally recover or agrees to accept as a payoff. The billed amount is the same whether the case settles for $25,000 or $500,000. Legal caps, reductions and negotiation decide the payoff, which is why lien work matters most in smaller cases.
How is the attorney fee calculated?
Most injury lawyers work on a contingency fee: a percentage of what you recover, set out in a written agreement you sign at the start. Under Business and Professions Code section 6147, that agreement must state the fee rate, explain how costs affect the fee and your recovery, and say the fee is not set by law and is negotiable.
One detail changes your net more than people expect: whether the fee is figured on the gross or after costs come out. On a $100,000 settlement with $4,000 in costs, 33% of the gross is $33,000. The same rate figured after costs is $31,680. Check which one your agreement uses, and read more about what it costs to hire a personal injury lawyer.
What are case costs?
Case costs are the out-of-pocket expenses of pursuing your claim, separate from the lawyer’s fee. The firm usually advances them and is paid back from the settlement. Typical costs include filing and service fees, medical records and police reports, deposition transcripts, expert witness fees, and mediator fees.
Costs are usually modest in a case that settles early and much higher in a case that goes deep into litigation, mostly because of experts. Ask who pays them if there is no recovery.
Which medical liens and reimbursement claims come out?
Anyone who paid for your accident-related care, or treated you on the promise of payment from the case, may have a right to be paid back from the settlement. The rules depend on who paid.
Medi-Cal
The state can recover what Medi-Cal paid for your accident-related care under Welfare and Institutions Code sections 14124.70 to 14124.795. Its recovery is limited to the part of your settlement that represents medical expenses, a limit that follows the U.S. Supreme Court’s Ahlborn and Wos decisions. If the settlement doesn’t separate that portion, a court may have to allocate it; in Daniel C. v. White Memorial Medical Center (2022), a California appeals court sent a case back so the past-medical-expense share could be set before Medi-Cal’s claim was fixed. The law also reduces the claim to account for attorney fees and costs, and it can’t take more than you net after fees and costs.
Medicare
Medicare must be repaid for accident-related care it covered when you settle with a liability insurer. It issues a demand after the settlement and reduces it to reflect your procurement costs, such as attorney fees and expenses. Federal rules call for repayment within 60 days, and interest can be charged if the debt isn’t resolved on time (42 C.F.R. section 411.24), so this needs prompt attention.
Health plans
For qualifying health plans, such as many HMOs and insured plans, Civil Code section 3040 can limit reimbursement to the lesser of the statutory amount (generally what the plan paid, plus its reasonable costs of perfecting the lien) or one-third of the money due to you when you have a lawyer. Further reductions for your attorney fees and costs, and for comparative fault found in a judgment, may apply. Section 3040 does not apply to Medi-Cal or hospital liens. Self-funded employer plans governed by the federal ERISA law are often outside it too, and their rights depend heavily on the plan’s written terms.
Hospital liens
Under Civil Code section 3045.1, a licensed hospital that provided emergency and ongoing care can claim a lien on your recovery for its reasonable and necessary charges. The hospital must give written notice, and hospital liens are limited, together, to 50 percent of the recovery after prior liens (Civil Code section 3045.4).
That cap limits what a qualifying hospital lien can take from your settlement. It doesn’t necessarily erase the hospital bill itself, so ask what, if anything, will still be owed after the lien is paid, and get the hospital’s final number in writing.
Med-pay and doctors who treated on a lien
If your own auto policy paid medical bills under “med-pay” coverage, your insurer may ask to be repaid, depending on your policy. If you treated with a doctor or clinic on a lien, they are paid from the settlement. See treating on a medical lien after an accident.
What else can come out of a settlement?
Two other items often reduce the check: money advanced to you before the case settled, and medical bills that are still unpaid. If you took pre-settlement funding, it is repaid from the settlement, often with substantial fees. See what to know about a personal injury case advance before you sign one.
Bills from providers who never filed a lien don’t disappear when your case settles. They are still your debt, so it usually makes sense to deal with them from the settlement rather than face collections later.
Can liens be reduced?
Often, yes. Reducing a valid lien generally increases what you receive, though the final distribution still depends on other liens, costs and the fee agreement. Some reductions are built into the law, like the attorney-fee adjustments for Medi-Cal, Medicare and many health plans. Others come from negotiation.
Common arguments for a reduction include billing errors, charges unrelated to the accident, low insurance limits, comparative fault, and the fact that you paid a lawyer to create the fund the lienholder is being paid from. Results vary, and no reduction is guaranteed.
Do you pay taxes on a personal injury settlement?
Usually not. Money you receive because of a physical injury or physical sickness is generally not taxable income under Internal Revenue Code section 104(a)(2). That includes compensation for medical bills, lost income and pain and suffering that flow from the physical injury.
IRS Publication 4345 lists the main exceptions:
- Punitive damages are taxable, even in a physical injury case.
- Interest paid on a settlement or judgment is taxable.
- Emotional distress without a physical injury is generally taxable, less certain medical costs for the distress.
- Medical expenses you already deducted in an earlier tax year may have to be reported as income, to the extent the deduction lowered your taxes.
How a settlement is worded can matter for taxes. Talk to a tax professional about your own situation before the settlement is signed.
What should your settlement statement show?
Before you receive your share, your lawyer should give you a written statement listing the gross amount, the fee and how it was calculated, each cost, each lien before and after any reduction, and your net amount. Ask about any line you don’t understand. When the money is actually paid out is covered in our guide on how long it takes to get paid after a settlement.
Frequently asked questions
What if my medical bills are more than my settlement?
This happens, especially when the at-fault driver has low insurance limits. Several liens have legal caps, such as the 50 percent limit on hospital liens and the one-third cap under Civil Code section 3040, and many lienholders will negotiate when the money simply isn’t there. Your lawyer should work through every lien before you accept so you know your likely net.
Can I negotiate liens myself without a lawyer?
Yes, you can ask any lienholder for a reduction. But some protections are smaller without a lawyer. Under Civil Code section 3040, a covered health plan’s claim can be capped at one-third of the money due to you if you hired an attorney, but one-half if you didn’t. Get every lienholder’s final number in writing before you accept a settlement.
Can I get some of my settlement while a lien is disputed?
Often, yes. California’s lawyer trust-account rule (Rule of Professional Conduct 1.15) requires a lawyer to promptly pay out funds that aren’t in dispute, and to keep a disputed amount in the trust account until the dispute is resolved. In practice, the undisputed share can be paid to you while enough is held back to cover the contested lien. Our guide on how long it takes to get paid after a settlement covers timing.
When should you talk to a lawyer about liens and your net settlement?
Before you accept an offer, especially if any of these apply.
- Your medical bills are close to, or more than, the available insurance limits.
- Medi-Cal, Medicare or a health plan paid for your care and will want to be repaid.
- A hospital has sent a lien notice, or you treated with a doctor on a lien.
- You took a settlement advance, or you have unpaid bills that could go to collections.
- You have an offer and don’t know your likely net after fees, costs and liens.
Want to know what you’d actually take home?
If you’re weighing a settlement offer and want a clear picture of your likely net, we can walk you through it. Contact our office or call (949) 313-7656 for a free consultation. You can also learn more about our Orange County personal injury practice.
This article is general information about California law, not legal or tax advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The examples above are hypothetical, not predictions or quotes. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
