Law Offices of Faud Haghighi

What Happens at Personal Injury Mediation in California?

Mediation is a confidential meeting where a neutral mediator helps you and the other side try to settle your injury case. The mediator can’t force a decision, and nothing is settled unless you agree to it. Most of the day is spent in separate rooms while the mediator carries offers back and forth. It usually lasts a half day or a full day. If you were hurt and your case is headed to mediation, our Orange County personal injury lawyer page explains how we can help.

What is mediation?

Mediation is a structured settlement negotiation run by a neutral third person, the mediator. The mediator is often a retired judge or an experienced lawyer. Their job is to help both sides find a number they can live with, not to decide who is right.

Mediation usually happens after a lawsuit is filed and the main evidence has been exchanged in discovery. By then, both sides know the strengths and weaknesses of the case. It can also happen before a lawsuit if both sides agree. See do you have to file a lawsuit? for how that decision is made.

Who attends?

Usually you, your lawyer, the defense lawyer, a representative of the insurance company, and the mediator. The insurance representative is the person with authority to approve a settlement. Sometimes they join by phone or video instead of in person.

Many mediations now take place by video call, with each side in its own virtual room. In-person sessions are often held at the mediator’s office. Either way, you don’t have to speak directly to the other side unless you and your lawyer decide it would help.

How the day usually goes

Most of the day is a series of private meetings, with the mediator moving between rooms carrying offers and arguments. This back-and-forth is often called “shuttle diplomacy.” A typical day has five stages:

  1. Preparation. Each side sends the mediator a confidential brief about the facts, injuries and damages. Your role: review the key facts with your lawyer.
  2. Opening. The mediator explains the ground rules. Some mediators hold a joint session, many skip it. Your role: listen. Your lawyer does the talking.
  3. Private sessions (caucus). The mediator meets with each side separately and carries offers and counteroffers between rooms, often in several rounds. Your role: be candid with the mediator and decide each move with your lawyer.
  4. Possible agreement. The sides may reach a number on their own, or the mediator may suggest one (a mediator’s proposal). Your role: decide whether to accept.
  5. Written agreement, or back to litigation. If you settle, the terms are written down and signed. If not, the case continues. Your role: read the terms before you sign.

Every mediator runs the day a little differently. Your lawyer can tell you what to expect from your mediator.

Early offers are often far apart, and that’s normal. The first few rounds can feel slow or even insulting. When movement comes, it often comes later in the day, but there’s no guarantee the gap will close.

How long does mediation take, and who pays for it?

Most personal injury mediations last a half day or a full day, and the mediator’s fee is usually split between the two sides. Plan to be available for the whole session, even if it ends early. Some cases need a second session or follow-up calls.

  • Private mediators. Most injury cases in Orange County use a private mediator the parties choose together. Private mediators set their own rates, often for a half-day or full-day session.
  • The court’s mediation panel. Orange County Superior Court also runs a civil mediation program. Under its program guidelines, panel mediators charge $300 for up to the first two hours, then their own hourly rate, and the parties share the fee equally unless they agree otherwise.
  • Your share. In many injury cases, your lawyer advances your share as a case cost, repaid from any recovery. Your fee agreement should say how costs are handled.

What helps cases settle at mediation?

Mediation puts everyone with authority to settle in one place on one day, with a neutral person testing each side’s risks. Several things tend to move the numbers:

  • The risk talk. In private, the mediator walks each side through what could go wrong at trial. Hearing it from a neutral person often changes minds on both sides.
  • Settlement authority. The insurance representative usually arrives with a limit. When the evidence justifies more, the mediator can push them to seek more authority that day.
  • Brackets. A bracket is a conditional offer: “We’ll go to this number if you come down to that one.” It helps both sides signal where they might end up without giving ground for nothing.
  • Policy limits. When a claim is worth more than the at-fault party’s insurance, the policy limit often becomes the practical ceiling, and the talk turns to other coverage.

Both sides arrive having already valued the case, usually starting from your demand letter. Read more about how a personal injury case is valued in California.

What is a mediator’s proposal?

A mediator’s proposal is a settlement number the mediator suggests when the two sides are stuck. Each side tells the mediator privately whether it accepts. If either says no, the other side never learns how its opponent answered, so each side can accept without looking weak. If both accept, they ordinarily put the agreement in writing. Whether it binds you depends on the written terms and California’s rules, explained below.

Is what you say at mediation confidential?

Yes. Under California Evidence Code section 1119, what is said and written for a mediation generally can’t be used as evidence or obtained in discovery later. That lets both sides talk openly about risks without it being used against them at trial.

The protection has limits. Under Evidence Code section 1120(a), evidence that is otherwise admissible or discoverable, such as your medical records or the police report, doesn’t become protected just because it was used in mediation.

The mediator also can’t report to the judge about who was reasonable or what was said. Under Evidence Code section 1121, a mediator’s report to the court can generally state only whether an agreement was reached.

Because these rules are strict, Evidence Code section 1129 requires your lawyer to explain mediation confidentiality to you in a one-page written disclosure, and to have you sign it, before you agree to mediate. A missed disclosure, though, is not by itself a reason to undo a mediated settlement.

Do you have to settle at mediation?

No. You decide whether to accept any offer, and you can walk away without a deal. California’s ethics rules (Rule of Professional Conduct 1.2) say the decision to settle belongs to the client. Your lawyer will give you advice, but the choice is yours.

If you do reach an agreement, the key terms are usually written and signed before everyone leaves. Under Evidence Code section 1123, a signed written settlement made at mediation is generally admissible, and so enforceable, only if it says it is enforceable or binding or words to that effect (or meets another narrow condition). In Fair v. Bakhtiari (2006) 40 Cal.4th 189, the California Supreme Court held the writing must directly say the parties agree to be bound.

Once a binding agreement is signed, backing out is very difficult, so take breaks, ask questions and be sure before you sign.

How should you prepare?

  1. Go over the facts, your medical treatment and your current symptoms with your lawyer beforehand.
  2. Ask your lawyer for an estimate of what you would take home at different settlement amounts, after fees, costs and liens.
  3. Think about your goals and your limits, but stay open to new information during the day.
  4. Understand the risks of going to trial, including the defense’s main arguments and any weak spots in the evidence.
  5. Clear your schedule for the whole day. Bring snacks, any medication you need, and something to pass the time.
  6. If it’s a video mediation, find a quiet, private space with a reliable connection.

What happens if mediation doesn’t settle the case?

The case keeps moving toward trial, and settlement talks can continue. Some cases settle in the days or weeks after a mediation, sometimes with the mediator’s follow-up calls. If the case is in court, more discovery and expert witness work may follow.

Formal “998” offers

A failed mediation can be followed by a formal written settlement offer under Code of Civil Procedure section 998, which either side may serve. If you turn down a valid defense 998 offer and don’t do better at trial, you can’t recover your own costs from the date of the offer, must pay the defense’s costs from that date, and may be ordered to pay some of its expert fees. It works the other way too: if the defense rejects your 998 offer and you beat it, the court may order the defense to pay your expert costs. Comparing the offer with the result can involve additional rules, such as leaving out costs incurred after the offer.

The mandatory settlement conference

The court may also set a mandatory settlement conference under California Rules of Court, rule 3.1380. It differs from private mediation in four ways:

  • A judge or court-appointed officer runs it.
  • The parties, trial counsel and people with full authority to settle generally must attend unless the court excuses them. The court sets the appearance requirements, and it may allow remote attendance.
  • Each side submits a settlement conference statement at least five court days ahead, with a good-faith demand or offer.
  • The special mediation confidentiality statutes (Evidence Code sections 1115 to 1128) don’t apply to settlement conferences under this rule, according to the rule’s advisory committee comment.

If the case still doesn’t settle, it goes to trial. Read more about how a personal injury case moves through Orange County Superior Court.

Frequently asked questions

Will I have to tell my story in front of the defendant?

Usually not. Most of the day happens in separate rooms, and the person you’re making the claim against often isn’t there at all; their insurer and lawyer usually are. Your lawyer does most of the talking. Sometimes a short, honest account of how the injury changed your daily life helps, but that’s a choice you make with your lawyer ahead of time, never a requirement.

Can I bring a family member to mediation?

Often, yes, but ask your lawyer first. The mediator usually needs to know who is coming, and some conversations with your lawyer may need to happen with just the two of you. A spouse who is also a party to the case attends anyway. A calm supporter can help on a long day; someone who pushes you toward a number usually doesn’t.

Is mediation the same as arbitration?

No. A mediator helps the two sides negotiate but decides nothing. An arbitrator hears the evidence and makes a decision, much like a judge. If the arbitration is binding, that decision is very hard to undo. In mediation, nothing happens unless you agree to it.

When should you talk to a lawyer about mediation?

Well before the mediation date, especially if any of these apply.

  • The other side has proposed mediation and you don’t have a lawyer yet.
  • You’ve been asked to sign a mediation confidentiality disclosure or a settlement agreement.
  • You don’t know what you would take home after fees, costs and liens at different settlement amounts.
  • The mediator has made a proposal and you’re unsure whether to accept it.
  • Mediation didn’t settle the case and you’ve received a formal 998 offer.

Have a mediation coming up?

If your Orange County injury case is heading to mediation, or you want to know whether it should, we can help you understand where you stand. Contact our office or call (949) 313-7656 for a free consultation. You can also learn more about our Orange County personal injury practice.

This article is general information about California law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Fees and timeframes are general examples, not predictions. Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

No Fee Unless We Win

Free Case Review

Speak directly with an attorney about your injury — at no cost.

(949) 313-7656 Request a Consultation
Faud Haghighi, Esq., Orange County personal injury attorney
Meet Your Attorney

Faud Haghighi, Esq.

Founder & Lead Trial Attorney

An Orange County trial attorney representing people injured by someone else's negligence — in car and truck crashes, slip-and-falls, premises accidents, and other serious-injury cases. Faud builds each case with the right medical and liability experts, preserves the evidence early, and prepares every file for trial — and you work directly with him, start to finish.

CA State Bar since 2012 · Aliso Viejo & Tustin

Free Consultation Read full bio ›